Why this was flagged
Many providers in separate suites of one building
This building hosts providers registered across 3 different suite or unit numbers, a pattern seen when shell agencies are set up side by side.
Source CMS Hospice Enrollments · record as of 27 Jul 2026 · pulled 18 Sept 2026 · version 2026-09-18 · 641824
Owner is tied to 12 providers
An owner or managing party of this provider (ROBERT B STILLMAN) is listed on 12 separate Medicare enrollments. Chains are legal, but rapid multi-entity accumulation is a common structure in healthcare fraud cases.
Source CMS Hospice All Owners · record as of 19 Aug 2026 · pulled 18 Sept 2026 · version 2026-09-18 · ed1513
3 providers share this street address
This address is the registered location of 3 separate Medicare-enrolled providers. Legitimate causes exist (shared medical office buildings, management companies), but dense clustering of billing entities at one address is a known fraud pattern.
Source CMS Hospice Enrollments · record as of 27 Jul 2026 · pulled 18 Sept 2026 · version 2026-09-18 · 641824
Other providers at this street address (2)
Owners and managing parties of record
LAURENCE C GUMINA
OPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL · I · 100% ownership · since Dec 28, 2011
Source CMS Hospice All Owners · record as of 19 Aug 2026 · pulled 18 Sept 2026 · version 2026-09-18 · ed1513
BARBARA ROSHON
CORPORATE DIRECTOR · I · 0% ownership · since Jul 1, 2020
Source CMS Hospice All Owners · record as of 19 Aug 2026 · pulled 18 Sept 2026 · version 2026-09-18 · ed1513
RAAFAT ZAKI
CORPORATE DIRECTOR · I · 0% ownership · since Jul 1, 2018
Source CMS Hospice All Owners · record as of 19 Aug 2026 · pulled 18 Sept 2026 · version 2026-09-18 · ed1513
ROBERT F NAPLES
CONTRACTED MANAGING EMPLOYEE · I · 0% ownership · since Sep 26, 2014
Source CMS Hospice All Owners · record as of 19 Aug 2026 · pulled 18 Sept 2026 · version 2026-09-18 · ed1513
SARAH HADLEY
W-2 MANAGING EMPLOYEE · I · 0% ownership · since May 19, 2010
Source CMS Hospice All Owners · record as of 19 Aug 2026 · pulled 18 Sept 2026 · version 2026-09-18 · ed1513
KEVIN L FUTRYK
CORPORATE DIRECTOR · I · since Jul 1, 2018
Source CMS Hospice All Owners · record as of 19 Aug 2026 · pulled 18 Sept 2026 · version 2026-09-18 · ed1513
LAURENCE C GUMINA
CORPORATE DIRECTOR · I · since Feb 12, 2015
Source CMS Hospice All Owners · record as of 19 Aug 2026 · pulled 18 Sept 2026 · version 2026-09-18 · ed1513
ROBERT B STILLMAN
CORPORATE OFFICER · I · since Apr 15, 2013
Source CMS Hospice All Owners · record as of 19 Aug 2026 · pulled 18 Sept 2026 · version 2026-09-18 · ed1513
PAUL M FLANNERY
CORPORATE DIRECTOR · I · since Jul 1, 2018
Source CMS Hospice All Owners · record as of 19 Aug 2026 · pulled 18 Sept 2026 · version 2026-09-18 · ed1513
Source timeline
Every flag on this provider is built from one or more published government files. Below is each file that contributed, the weekly pulls we have of it, and the actual records read from it.
CMS Hospice Enrollments
- Many providers in separate suites of one building
- 3 providers share this street address
Weekly refreshes
- 18 Sept 2026 (in use)5,802 records5,000 added · 1 changed · 0 removedpublisher data as of 27 Jul 2026
Records read from this file
- OHIO LIVING HOLDINGSNPI 1386032373 · certification 361696 · 6715 TIPPECANOE ROAD, CANFIELD, OH
- OHIO LIVING HOLDINGSsame street address in the same file
- ALL CARING HOSPICE, LLCsame street address in the same file
CMS Hospice All Owners
- Owner is tied to 12 providers
Weekly refreshes
- 18 Sept 2026 (in use)70,444 recordspublisher data as of 19 Aug 2026
Records read from this file
- LAURENCE C GUMINAOPERATIONAL/MANAGERIAL CONTROL · 100% share · since 2011-12-28
- BARBARA ROSHONCORPORATE DIRECTOR · 0% share · since 2020-07-01
- RAAFAT ZAKICORPORATE DIRECTOR · 0% share · since 2018-07-01
- ROBERT F NAPLESCONTRACTED MANAGING EMPLOYEE · 0% share · since 2014-09-26
- SARAH HADLEYW-2 MANAGING EMPLOYEE · 0% share · since 2010-05-19
- KEVIN L FUTRYKCORPORATE DIRECTOR · since 2018-07-01
- LAURENCE C GUMINACORPORATE DIRECTOR · since 2015-02-12
- ROBERT B STILLMANCORPORATE OFFICER · since 2013-04-15
cms_hospice_payments
No completed weekly pull is recorded for this file yet.
Records read from this file
- Ohio Living Hospice - Greater Youngstown — 2024$4,189,746 paid · 284 patients
Where every detail came from
Each value below is traced to the published file it was read from, the day we downloaded it, and the weekly version it belongs to. Open the link to check the original record yourself.
| Detail | Value | Published file | Record as of | Pulled | Version |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Legal name | OHIO LIVING HOLDINGS | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
| Trading name | OHIO LIVING HOSPICE - GREATER YOUNGSTOWN | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
| NPI | 1386032373 | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
| Medicare certification number | 361696 | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
| CMS associate ID | 8729111471 | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
| Provider type | PART A PROVIDER - HOSPICE | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
| Organisation type | CORPORATION | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
| Incorporation date | 2010-05-19 | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
| State of incorporation | OH | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
| Street address | 6715 TIPPECANOE ROAD, BUILDING E SUITE 201 | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
| City | CANFIELD | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
| State | OH | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
| ZIP | 44406 | CMS Hospice Enrollments | Jul 27, 2026 | Sep 18, 2026 | 2026-09-18 · 641824 |
What changed
How this provider's public record has moved between weekly refreshes. See the whole week.
Nothing has changed for this provider since we started comparing weekly refreshes.
Public research history
Nobody has worked this lead yet. Notes published by investigators stay here even after a claim expires.
Readers judge whether this flag holds up. A note only reaches the top when people who usually disagree both rate it helpful.
No notes yet. If you have checked this provider, say what you found.